The Bible is a collection of books, a proper library of books. Reading and understanding it is the wish of many people. Everyone approaches the book with certain presuppositions and ideas. These are perspectives. It helps to be aware of one’s own presuppositions.
In churches, communities, Bible schools and theological faculties there are different perspectives on the Bible. Students are familiarised with (new) viewpoints. That is fundamentally good and exciting. They remain interpretations, however.
In my experience, these interpretations often end up as presuppositions with which the Bible is read. As humans, we have to interpret, and we live with presuppositions every day. Such perspectives are something like cognitive filters that simplify the world. They make it possible for us to cope in this world. One could also recognise these perspectives as “bubbles” in which one moves. Being aware of this helps not to get caught up in trench warfare over “correct views”.
Simplifying the world
The power of presuppositions lies in simplification. One presupposition is this: “The Bible does not contradict itself.” That is not something the Bible teaches, but a derived understanding. Once established, it can be tacitly placed in front of any interpretation. It is not the only variant, however. A brief list of (sometimes contradictory) preconceptions that I have regularly encountered. It should be explicitly noted that these are not the only points, and that some viewpoints attempt to explain and harmonize these contradictory impressions.
- The Bible is the word of God.
- The Bible is a human word.
- The Bible contradicts itself constantly.
- The Bible never contradicts itself.
- The Bible speaks of a loving God.
- The Bible speaks of a God who loves violence, or even of a vengeful God.
Every statement is a particular understanding. Imagine that you agree with one of the statements on this list. You probably then have reasons why this or that statement matters to you. Soberly considered, the reason does not even have to be objectively true, as long as you accept it as “true”. It is the personal or accepted view. Perhaps it is correct, perhaps not; I deliberately do not want to settle that here. As a mechanism, however, one’s own view fulfils a function. What interests me here is the effect and function of the presuppositions.
These and other ideas are often placed in front of the reading of the Bible. They are something like the glasses through which one looks at the Bible. In this way, the understanding of how one views the world is shaped. Ideologies work like this. Here one could ask where faith ends and ideology begins. Most people, whether believers in their own understanding or not, stand in this field of tension between authentic life and faith on the one hand and given or preferred ideas on the other.
Beliefs are often nothing other than religious ideologies. Conversely, one could also say that ideologies are something like beliefs. They are (often fixed) ideas about how the world works and what is “true”, about who belongs to the “good” and whom to the “bad”. This is not a judgement but the description of a principle. The principle is not wrong but human. I mention this deliberately because I am interested in the question of what constitutes the essence of faith.
Once I made the personal choice to use the Bible as the source for my questions of faith. I expressly did not want to follow certain ideas blindly, but to engage with the Bible openly and curiously. I was eager to discover how God is attested in the Bible and what outlook I would gain. My adventure of faith began there. Since then, I have engaged with it critically and self-critically. It is something like a developmental process. Some of the presuppositions in the list above I held for a long time. Others I rejected just as resolutely because they seemed incompatible with my own presuppositions.
When I became aware of these mechanisms, I began to handle my own presuppositions more carefully. I recognised them as presuppositions and thereby as my personal decisions. Presuppositions and ideologies are not divine but human. I became more cautious because I was aware of my own limitations. I try to avoid confusing “my insights” with “absolute truth”. In the words of the Bible, it is about acknowledging the difference between “man” and “God” (Job 33:12).
People can believe
Beliefs arise because people can believe. At first this is not about the content but about the ability. It is the ability to believe, just as we can move, breathe and think. This ability is valuable and human. What we believe, by contrast, is something else. We often accept the content of faith from others, or work it out over time. The difference between the two is therefore this: the ability to believe is innate. The content of faith is acquired later in life.
What we come to accept as “true” over time are variants of human imagination. Fixed ideas about how the world works are found in the form of beliefs, ideologies (political, theological or religious in nature) or also conspiracy myths. They all fulfil a function for human beings. The mechanisms behind them appear astonishingly similar, which is why I name them together here. They are all “constructs of belief” and help us to orient our lives. Often it is also true that our complex world appears simpler, more understandable, more comprehensible or even more meaningful through these ideas.
This notion upsets quite a few things we take for granted. I expressly am not concerned with the content of these ideas, but with the mechanisms that shape them. It is equally about the function of these ideas for the believer. What is often problematic about the content is that a sober examination of the statements is not desired. This confirms the idea as a fixed idea. Conspiracy myths, ideologies and many an internalised belief remain in place as a worldview and understanding of the world, even when they offer no sober basis.
Two questions remain after this reflection:
- What do I choose as the content of my faith, and why?
- How does ideology differ from a “living faith”?
Choosing a perspective
With the preceding thoughts in mind, one can now approach the interpretation of the Bible. How does one interpret the Bible? Which perspective does one take?
Sometimes one hears something like “the Bible says”. If an interpretation begins with such an idea, it is reasonable to suspect that one is beginning with a presupposition. That is not wrong, but often undeclared. Everyone works with presuppositions because that simplifies a process of interpretation. Which presuppositions we have internalised and use as a starting point does, however, differ from person to person. There are advantages and disadvantages to presuppositions. On the one hand, they enable certain views and interpretations. On the other hand, they prevent other aspects from being clarified.
Perhaps this idea helps: if one regards assumptions as lookout towers, it is easier to see that each assumption offers a different view. Or one regards assumptions as different shoes with which to explore this world. The difference between hiking boots, trainers and dancing shoes is real, but they were made for different uses. In the same way every presupposition has its very own strengths and weaknesses, and what one can explore with it is different for each type.
Presuppositions are often not only individual but form the background of a culture or of the understanding of a faith community. This is why sermons and topics differ from church to church or from denomination to denomination. Every faith community has its own culture and its own presuppositions. If one feels at home in it, one usually accepts its statements. If one comes from a different tradition, however, the difference can stand out. Why is it interpreted “this” way here and “that” way there?
The perspectives in looking at the Bible result from the “framework” used to construct the ideas. A framework is often built on a whole series of assumptions, which together provide something like a foundation.
A typical presupposition is, for example, that the entire New Testament speaks of today’s church. The starting point or presupposition often seems to work like this: wherever Jesus is mentioned, it concerns us. This is why there are especially many sermons on the Gospels, as if these applied “literally” to today’s Christianity. The problem here, however, is that statements of the Gospels were never addressed to today’s church from all Gentile nations (Matt 15:24; Rom 15:8). There was no “body of Christ”, no “community from all Gentile nations” in the time of the Gospels, and cross and resurrection come only at the end of these accounts.
The contradiction of such a “building block” for the framework of faith lies here: on the one hand Christians live from the power of the resurrection, but preaching is from the Gospels, mostly from the time before cross and resurrection. The chosen perspective appears incomplete and undifferentiated, even if one can take much good from the Gospels (in a figurative sense). This has to do with theological assumptions and an internalised culture. This contradiction can become a real challenge. They lead, for example, to statements of the Gospels (healings, supposed notions of hell, end-time expectations) suddenly being transferred to a present-day understanding of faith and then causing irresolvable conflicts.
Disclosing the presuppositions
An interpretation of the Bible that is as neutral as possible benefits from disclosing one’s presuppositions. This is also one reason why the basis is declared right away on the homepage of this website: “This project engages with Evangelical thought based on the Bible.” What is not mentioned, by contrast, is my personal position. It can be partly deduced from the texts. On the other hand, I usually think about certain standpoints for a long time before I write anything about them. The declaration is correct for the website and describes something like a journey experience in retrospect. What I am currently working on is hardly mentioned because I am still working on it. A strategic orientation of the website also means that some topics are given more weight than others.
The content and orientation of the website are declared. This is a deliberately chosen openness. It allows every visitor to judge for themselves whether this subject is interesting for their own reflections. The aim is to enable transparency and openness where I often did not find it. Topics are named so that they can be discussed.
There are various ways to approach an examination of, say, evangelical thought. I very deliberately choose an “examination based on the Bible” and try to let the text speak for itself—not as “see, that’s my opinion,” but as “what did the writer want to convey to his original audience?” This is both a choice and an experiment. I do this because I have noticed this difference:
- I have taken a great deal of good from the Bible. That is my personal motivation.
- I have also seen how presuppositions block the view of the text. That is where ideological assumptions begin.
The challenge here, however, is this: people think differently. A reference to the Bible can carry a particular stamp, which is classified as “dogmatic”, “biblical”, “scientific” or otherwise. This classification is perhaps well justified, but it is considerably more than just a direction. Often it is an understanding of what may count and what may not. These are presuppositions that are used for the permitted, desired or imagined understanding of the Bible.
As a pragmatic direction of interpretation one can ask two basic questions:
- Why and about what does the writer speak?
- What was his aim?
With these questions, I learn to first understand what is named in the text. That is the first step towards a more many-sided understanding. Luke, for example, wrote for a man named Theophilus (Luke 1:3; Acts 1:1). He was the readership for whom Luke wrote. This has nothing directly to do with a present-day church. Nevertheless, I can learn a great deal from these books. When I recognise something valuable in them, I take it on as an inspiration. That is a next step. I consider that I can learn even if something is not “literally” true, or was never addressed directly to me.
What we choose
The position we take is a choice. It can be made consciously or unconsciously, and can have good or less good reasons. What everyone can strive for is a better understanding. Growth lies waiting there, and perhaps new horizons await us.
In understanding the Bible one can consciously choose perspectives, but also integrate new ones. The familiar teaching, whichever it may be, can be supplemented by other views. That does not mean one has to agree with everything, but that one sees several interpretations. Behind the interpretations there are often assumptions that one can explore. Certain teachings contradict, for example, other Bible passages that one reads. Why is that?
One can ask many further questions, for example:
- Is everything in the Bible to be understood literally? What about figurative language, then?
- If Moses is the author of the Torah, where did he get the information about the time before him, and who described his death (Deut. 34:5)?
- Since we are already talking about creation: are the first two chapters of the Bible two aspects of the same event, or are they two different accounts? Why?
Our choices are reflected in the answers we give. When certain approaches to understanding fail to clarify specific questions (sufficiently), other approaches can probably provide helpful insights. While this does not result in a perfect interpretation of the Bible, it does broaden our horizons. Does this encourage a new perspective on studying the Bible?

